The Shack

4.7$· InexpensiveClosed · closed today

Savor delicious smoked barbecue and fresh donuts near Keuka Lake.

The Shack
Website Directions 315-531-8700

Located in Penn Yan in the Finger Lakes region, The BBQ Shack serves classic comfort foods like tender brisket, pulled pork, and savory sides. Visitors can enjoy generous portions alongside freshly made donuts in a casual, welcoming setting. It is a convenient stop for a satisfying meal, offering both dine-in and quick takeout options.

Quick tip: Save room for dessert and grab a fresh donut to round out your meal.

Expert notes

  • Arrive early for a better table during peak hours.
  • Check the daily specials for unique menu items.
  • Consider making a reservation on weekends.
  • Try their signature cocktails for a refreshing drink.
  • Don't miss the dessert menu for a sweet treat after your meal.

Features

  • Family-friendly atmosphere
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Full bar
  • Live music
  • Outdoor seating
  • Parking available
  • Pet-friendly
  • Seasonal menu
  • Takeout available
  • Waterfront views

Special occasion reservations

  • Reservations can be made by calling the restaurant directly.
  • Online reservations may be available on the website.

More places to eat in Finger Lakes

All places to eat in Finger Lakes →