Key West Key Lime Pie Co.
4.4$· InexpensiveIconic Key West dessert spot serving handcrafted classic key lime pies
Located on Greene Street in Key West, Key West Key Lime Pie Co. is famous for its smooth, creamy key lime pies featuring a rich graham cracker crust. Visitors can enjoy individual slices, whole pies, pie-in-a-cup, and chocolate-dipped pie bars on a stick. The shop also serves key lime milkshakes and refreshing limeade for a quick island treat.
Expert notes
- Try the original key lime pie for the full experience.
- Ask about seasonal flavors and specials.
- Check for any daily discounts or promotions.
- Take a few boxes of key lime treats to share with friends.
- Enjoy the outdoor seating area if available.
- Visit early in the day for the freshest pies.
- Take photos of the quirky decor inside the shop.
- Inquire about their recipe if you're interested in making your own key lime pie.
- Consider visiting during off-peak hours to avoid crowds.
Features
- Family Friendly
- Free Samples
- Gift Shop
- Gluten-Free Options
- Local Ingredients
- Outdoor Seating
- Takeout Available
- Vegan Options
More places to eat in Key West
New York Pasta Garden$$Relaxed Italian dining and classic pasta dishes in Key West
Cuban Coffee Queen Downtown (Southard and Duval)$Authentic Cuban coffee, classic sandwiches, and relaxed shaded patio seating.
Salute! On The Beach$$Casual open-air Italian dining just steps from the ocean sand
Dante's Key West Pool Bar & Restaurant$$Lively Key West pool bar serving fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and music
The Lobster Shack Key West$Fresh Seafood Awaits at The Lobster Shack
Sunset Grille & Raw Bar$$Oceanfront dining and raw bar seafood near the Seven Mile Bridge